The 15 Waterproof Eyeliners You Can Count On

This satin kajal liner just made it easier to master a quick smoky effect. Simply blend out with the attached smudge-tool after lining your eyes.

Customer review: “This is the best eyeliner I’ve purchased. It stays in place, does not transfer and the color is perfect. I ordered burgundy and liked it so much I ordered another in brown.” —Karen M

These pencils come in both matte and shimmer finishes, in every color from basic black to bright teal. And most importantly, they’re also waterproof and smudge-proof for up to 24 hours.

Customer review: “This pencil is great! Applies easy, stays put and no fade. The caveat: always use an eye primer for easy application and smudge-proof wear. That’s the secret for any eye makeup addict.”

This super smooth liner effortlessly glides on, leaving behind the perfect line of bold pigment.

Customer review: “These Kulfi Long Wear Eye liners are worth the hype. They don’t budge! I have the color rain check, a beautiful blue. It’s very pigmented and applies so smoothly—no tugging! They set so well and stayed put all day long! Makes me wanna try more colors!”

This pigment-rich clean formula works just as well for your waterline as it does splashed across your lids, doubling as an eye shadow.

Customer review: “This is the best eyeliner I have ever bought. Glides on smoothly and the blender on the other end is soft but effective at softening the look.” —Hollie

Clean ingredients aside, this liner would earn a place in the Liquid Liner Hall of Fame based on its precise application and stay-put formula alone.

Customer review: “I’m more of a classic pencil gal so I was hesitant to try this. But I’m glad I did! Stays put and takes little time to apply.” —Kimberly

Danessa Myricks Beauty is all about makeup artist flexibility—and this eye color doesn’t disappoint. Use it as a waterproof eyeliner one day, then blend it out before it sets to try the shade as an eye shadow the next.

Customer review: “I have found my new perfect eyeliner. Goes on easily and washed off thoroughly. And the contents in the jar don’t dry out very quickly.” —Harriet L

This little pot of gel liner has a tiny brush to help you apply a look that lasts up to 24 hours.

Customer review: “I’ve tried other gels from expensive, reputable companies but this one really stands out.” —Boo1954

Like the best-selling mascara that shares its name, this intense, long-lasting liquid liner promises a, well, mind-blowing application.

Customer review: “This is one of the best marker type liquid liners. So easy to use and super pigmented. Definitely a staple in my makeup routine.” —paisleysummer

If you prefer a more blended, soft line, look no further: Unlike a lot of waterproof liners that draw rigid lines, this pencil has a kohl-like finish.

Customer review: “As a woman over 50, this is the best, smoothest liner I’ve found. It glides on so easily and stays put. I bought the Marlene Midnight....it is a great alternative to basic black! Goodbye old, hard eye pencils!” —alanes

You don’t have to spend a fortune to get a black eyeliner that really lasts. Work quickly with this one, because once it sets, you’ll need an oily makeup remover to get it off.

Customer review: “I’ve tried numerous brands of ‘long wearing’ eyeliner even the most expensive ones, but this liner beats them all. Other liners smudge onto my contact lenses. L’Oréal stays put all day right where I apply it.” —Yammas

Used backstage at many top runway shows (and by one Taylor Swift on her Eras Tour), this inky and super-black liquid liner is best wielded by a skilled liner enthusiast. It’s a little too liquid for beginners.

Customer review: “I’ve re-bought this at least five times. You will not get a blacker liner with such precision and fast-drying results. Just call off the dogs, the search is over.” —rswerdlw

The thin pencil can be drawn in super close to your lash line or blended with the smudge tip—either way, your look is set for up to 24 hours.

Customer review: “Stays put! I love this eyeliner. A big part of my day used to be wiping under my eyes for smeared eyeliner. Not anymore! This stuff is great, it’s creamy when it goes on…you have a few seconds to adjust…and then it stays put. Definitely need real makeup remover to remove.”

The formula is reminiscent of the Pat McGrath liner, except Rihanna’s version has an even longer and pointier felt tip. Use it to stamp the perfect wing at the outer corner of your eyes, then trace the line across your lid.

Customer review: “Love this so much. Doesn’t smudge or move especially when you sweat. It stays all day and it’s super pigmented. It’s amazing.” —Jasmine594

There is no excuse not to have this $3 waterproof eyeliner in your makeup kit. Once you try it, you might never understand why you ever spent more than the price of a can of Coke on eyeliner.

Customer review: “The lines are quite surprising from such an inexpensive liner. I have bought brown and black and will continue to buy this pencil!” —CO

The smoothest and creamiest waterproof eyeliner we’ve ever tried, in shades you didn’t even know you needed.

Customer review: “I keep repurchasing UD eyeliners. They apply smoothly and have staying power.” —CRHI