Cult Drugstore Faves, Updated

Before highlights were an option, we'd sneak Sun In with our besties and feel like the peak of chic. The sun's rays activate the natural lemon in the new version, yielding a believable, non-brassy glimmer. Sun In Spray-In Hair Lightener, $4.99, ulta.com; John Frieda BEACHblonde Sun Streaks Lightening Spray, $9.99, ulta.com.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with the original beauty bar. But the more masculine scent—zippy, fresh, not at all musky—is a nice plan B when feminine/floral doesn't fit your mood. Dove White Beauty Bar, $9.39, target.com; Dove Men + Care Clean Comfort Body & Face Bar, $6.88, walmart.com.

Satisfyingly large cloths are soaked with the same bracing blend of anti-inflammatory witch hazel, lifting makeup and grime with nary a soggy cotton ball in sight. Dickinson's Original Witch Hazel Toner, $5.99, walgreens.com; Dickinson's Original Witch Hazel Cleansing Cloths, $6.99, walgreen.com.

If you've forgotten the scent of the original—and our guess is that you haven't—we're willing to bet you haven't forgotten the commercials. The new blackberry, cassia, sandalwood and plum scent is all grown-up, and every bit as, er, ecstasy-inducing. Herbal Essences Smooth Collection Shampoo and Conditioner, $3.39 each, target.com; Herbal Essences Wild Natural Rejuvenating Shampoo and Conditioner, $5.99 each, target.com.

We've yet to interview a hairstylist who didn't rave about the original drugstore dry shampoo. The new dry oil formula—which leaves hair soft and tousled, not greasy—is well on its way to being another cult fave. psssst! Instant Dry Shampoo, $4.99, walgreen.com; psssst! Sheer Dry Oil Finish Spray, $6.99, ulta.com.

It used to be you had to have da Vinci level brush skills to pull-off a precise cat-eye. The stiff, chunky tip is as easy to control as a magic marker, delivering both crisp lines and shiny pigment. Maybelline Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner, $4.79, target.com. Maybelline Eye Studio Master Graphic Liquid Eyeliner, $6.99, target.com.